Occasional notes by the guy who maintains the RatzingerFanClub and the Pope Benedict XVI Fan Club.

"perhaps the most underrated
weblog at St. Blog's"
- I. Shawn McElhinney

Contact me at: blostopher "at" gmail.com
Like my blogging? - Buy me a book!

RSS Feed Current Blog

<< # St. Blog's Parish ? >>

Pope Benedict XVI Fan Club
Pope John Paul II
Benedict In America
Catholics in the Public Square
Cardinal Francis Arinze
Hans Urs von Balthasar
Cardinal Avery Dulles

Catholic Just War Tradition
Catholic Friends of Israel
Catholic Church and Liberal Tradition
Pope Pius XII
The Da Vinci Code
Fr. John Courtney Murray
Richard J. Neuhaus
George Weigel
Michael Novak
George Weigel
Tolkien
Walker Percy
Prayer for Those in Service
in Time of War

Almighty God, our heavenly Father, let thy protection be upon all those who are in the service of our country; guard them from all harm and danger of body and soul; sustain and comfort those as home, especially in their hours of loneliness, anxiety, and sorrow; prepare the dying for death and the living for your service; give success to our arms on land and sea and in the air; and grant unto us and all nations a speedy, just and lasting peace. Amen.

Please Note: Recognition of the following blogs & periodicals should not be considered personal endorsement of the opinions contained therein, especially when content is not consistent with Church teaching.

RECENT POSTS

Remembering Martin Luther King, Jr.
Impressions of "Radical Orthodoxy"
Reading Thomas Aquinas - Recommended Aids & Introd...
Here and There . . .
Catholic Martyrs in 2005
Matthew Anger - "Watching the Fringe"
Ken Masugi's Advent Interviews with Fr. James V. S...
Hugh Hewitt interviews Fr. Joseph Fessio on Islam ...
Christmas - Hickory, NC 2005
And God Became Flesh

Ignatius Press - Catholic Books

BLOGS I READ

Religiously-Oriented

Blogroll Me!

"Secular"

<< # Catholic Bloggers ? >>

Periodicals:

Religious

Canticle Magazine
Chiesa
Christianity Today
Communio
Commonweal
Cross Currents
Crisis Magazine
First Things
InsideCatholic.com
Inside the Vatican
Lay Witness
Mennonite Quarterly Review
National Catholic Register
New Atlantis
New Oxford Review
The New Pantagruel
Perspectives
Second Spring
Saint Austin Review
The Tablet [U.K.]
Thirty Days
Touchstone
Traces

Secular

The American Conservative
American Outlook
The American Spectator
The Atlantic
Claremont Review of Books
City Journal
Commentary
The Economist
Foreign Affairs
Hoover Digest
Middle East Quarterly
National Review
The New Atlantis
The New Criterion
The New Republic
Newsweek
New York Review of Books
Orbis
OpinionJournal.Com
Policy Review
The Public Interest
Weekly Standard
Wilson Quarterly

Newspapers - (Daily)

Al-Ahram
The Guardian
Ha'aretz
The Independant
The Jerusalem Post
The New York Times
New York Post
Times Online (U.K.)
Washington Post
The Washington Times

Newspapers - (Weekly or Monthly)

The Forward
Houston Catholic Worker Newspaper
The Jewish Week
New York Press
The NonViolent Activist
Role Call
Zinda Magazine

Online Commentary
BeliefNet
Catholic Exchange
FrontPagMag.com
CruxNews
GodSpy
Spirit Daily
WorldNetDaily
Word from Rome
by John Allen Jr.

News

BBC News
CNN.Com
DrudgeReport
FoxNews
Google News
Haaretz Daily
New York Times
Times Online (U.K.)
Washington Times
Yahoo News

For an Occasional Laugh:

The Onion

Hungry? Order Online from Delivery.com

[Powered by Blogger]

Locations of visitors to this page
Blogarama
Subscribe with Bloglines

This Site Adheres to the Welborn Protocol: All correspondence is blogable unless you specifically request otherwise.

DISCLAIMER: The opinions expressed on this blog do not necessarily reflect those held by Pope Benedict XVI or other members of the 'Ratzinger Fan Club' website, which serves as host to this online journal.

COMMENTS POLICY (inspired by Donald Sensing):

  • No profanity!
  • No personal attacks.
  • No commercial commenting (links to your own blog site or relevant URL's permitted).
  • Keep in mind I have a day job -- hence, no time to respond to any and all comments. When I do so, it's as time permits.
  • Lastly, think before you post, and be considerate of others. Your comments may be recorded for posterity -- or the duration of Haloscan's memory.
  • Wednesday, January 18, 2006

    Aquinas and Academic Bias

    A reader inquires:
    I'm currently studying for a masters in counseling and am taking a course on Psychological testing. The text is Psychological Testing and Assessment - An Introduction to Tests and Measurements (McGraw-Hill, 6th Edition) by Ronald J. Cohen & Mark E. Swerdlik. The inside cover contains "a decidedly noncomprehensive historical overview of events in the field as they stand out in the minds of the authors"

    The bias of the authors against religion is apparent - "200 AD, science takes a backseat to faith and superstition" and 313 AD "Christianity is established as the state religion of the Roman Empire and "medical practice" (prayers, potions and magic) is in the hands of the clergy."

    And then to the reason I'm writing - 1265 "Thomas Aquinas argues that the notion of a human capacity to think and reason should be replaced with the notion of an immortal soul."

    Now ... I have not read much Aquinas, but am certain in the little I've done that this is an inaccurate summary of his work, to say the least.However, I do not have the background (or the time) to be able to refute this statement. Even so, I feel a duty to write the authors and correct the error.

    So my plea to you - can you direct me to some specific works of Thomas Aquinas that would refute this statement? Any direction would be helpful. If you can summarize a position and give some references, that would be fantastic. As someone who apparently understands and appreciates his work, you may be interested in helping correct this error. If so, I'd be grateful for any help you could provide.

    There's academic bias against Christianity, but this really takes the cake. Off the top of my head I don't think I could point to a single passage, but somebody else aquainted with the Summa might. The statement is completely off-base to the point of being comical, given Aquinas' confidence in human reasoning (for instance reason as an aid to faith in knowing the existence of God).

    Responses from our readers?

    |